The black roof thing on SUVs when done right I think looks kinda cool.. but its not flattering on this truck. I'm glad I opted not to do it, plus I wanted the FX4 package and it (for whatever reason?) doesn't combine with first edition.
I think it looks pretty good. I was already planning on the Lariat Lux with a Moon Roof and Tonneau Cover, so the price difference is only $140. For that, I think the black roof and mirrors look awesome.
But style is subjective, and I guess it is a bit of a departure from a more traditional truck look, so I'm not surprised that some people are hating on it.